Best Seafood in Carmel

Picture of Clean Plate Club

Clean Plate Club

The job of delivering the best possible content for our restaurant recommendations can not be left to one person. Click here to meet the team behind the Clean Plate Club.

Come up from the beach and enjoy the bounty of the sea. Carmel has plenty of sights to see and places to explore, and amongst the historic streets is some truly delectable seafood. If you’re on a more relaxed vacation, or taking the kids for a weekend, there’s a number of casual spots to grab fish that could be served at a five star restaurant, and if you want to spring for something extravagant, this list has you covered there too.

Feature Photo: Courtesy of Pangaea Grill

A table setting features a plate of shrimp pasta garnished with a purple orchid, showcasing some of the best seafood Carmel has to offer, alongside a bowl of creamy soup, a caesar salad, and a chicken dish with rice, all arranged on white plates. A drink in a tall glass is partially visible in the background.
Photo: Pangaea Grill

Pangaea Grill has won numerous awards for excellence over the years, including the title of “Best Restaurant of 2022 in Carmel-by-the-Sea.” But don’t just take our word for it, dine there yourself and experience award-winning food and top-notch service. Try their sand dabs with a lemongrass caper butter sauce, or go for their New England clam chowder, a classic favorite executed to perfection at Pangaea Grill.

A white rectangular plate holds grilled shrimp skewers garnished with chopped herbs, served on a bed of greens and diced red bell peppers. A small round dish with a creamy white dipping sauce and two lemon wedges are placed on the side, showcasing the best seafood Carmel offers.
Photo: The Grill on Ocean Ave

For a perfect seafood dinner, look no further than The Grill on Ocean Ave, right in the middle of Carmel. Try their classic shrimp scampi with fresh linguini, or go for their seafood fettuccine with tiger prawns and sea scallops. Coming for lunch? Don’t miss out on their piping hot fish and chips or their surf ‘n’ turf fajitas with garlic grilled shrimp and flat iron steak, served on maize tortillas.

A bread bowl filled with creamy clam chowder, garnished with chopped parsley. The chowder is slightly spilling over the edges of the bread. A piece of bread sits on the plate next to the bowl, with a blurry background of a glass and woven basket—arguably the best clam chowder on Monterey Peninsula.
Photo: Flaherty’s Seafood Grill & Oyster Bar

Arguably the top raw bar in Carmel-by-the-Sea does many things with freshness and style, including oysters, crab cakes, seafood Cobb salads, smart wines and inventive cocktails — and brings a lively atmosphere too. The chowder presents a house signature, and comes Manhattan red or creamy New England style. Side note: They also do a superlative crab chowder in bread bowls too.

Who’s writing these?

Meet our always-hungry team of foodies who compiled this list.
Please let us know if we’ve missed your favorite eat@localgetaways.com.

More Please!
For more suggestions on the best restaurants on the Monterey Peninsula, the best things to do on the Monterey Peninsula and the best places to stay on the Monterey Peninsula, click here.
Scroll to Top